Authenticity, Access, and the Case for Manufactured Scarcity

by Laurence Carpenter

For much of the twentieth century, scarcity in music memorabilia was accidental rather than designed. Instruments survived by chance, stage costumes were kept or discarded without thought of future value, and autographs were obtained informally, often with little or no documentation. This informality once gave the market its romance. Today, however, it also exposes its weaknesses.

As original artefacts have become increasingly valuable, they have migrated into museums, estates, and private collections, often placing them permanently beyond the reach of most collectors. At the same time, the secondary market has grown more uncertain. Autographs are questioned, ownership stories are hard to verify, and provenance can be patchy or reconstructed decades after the fact.

In this environment, manufactured scarcity has emerged not as a gimmick, but as a practical response to the twin pressures of authenticity and access.

Among high-end collectors, the idea of manufactured scarcity can provoke discomfort. Rarity, they argue, should be discovered, not designed. Cutting a stage-worn costume into fragments or dividing a historically important artefact feels, to some, like a violation of an artefact. That reaction is understandable. Yet this assumes that owning an original object is a realistic option for most collectors.

There is one original guitar, one original costume, one handwritten lyric sheet. Only a handful of individuals or institutions will ever own these items outright. Manufactured scarcity does not compete with that reality; it acknowledges it. By creating limited, controlled editions from authenticated source material, it offers a way for many collectors to participate meaningfully in music history where they otherwise could not.

The most visible example of this approach is the use of relic materials in trading cards. Stage-worn costumes, for instance, are first sourced from the artist or their management and then are fragmented, with each piece embedded into an officially licensed product. One object becomes many verified fragmented pieces connected to the same cultural moment.

Some view this process as sacrilege, but it offers multiple collectors the opportunity to own a piece rather than just one wealthy collector.

Authenticity is where manufactured scarcity most clearly distinguishes itself from the traditional secondary market. Buyers of vintage memorabilia frequently rely on trust: trust in the seller, trust in a signature obtained decades earlier, trust in a story that may have
passed through several hands. As values rise, so too does the incentive for misrepresentation, intentional or otherwise.

Licensed collectables significantly reduce that risk. Autographs are signed under formal agreement, witnessed, and documented. Relic materials should be sourced directly from authenticated items, with chain of custody established prior to being used in an officially licensed product. The result is not just rarity, but certainty — a quality that has become increasingly scarce in its own right.

Modern collectables also combine multiple layers of reassurance that were historically separate. Serial numbering defines the scale of scarcity and makes the limits explicit.

Autographs provide direct artist participation. Embedded relic pieces offer a physical connection to a specific moment or performance. Protective card holders preserve condition from the outset. Official licensing confirms that rights have been cleared and participation
authorised. Increasingly, these items are also compatible with third-party grading services, allowing collectors to encapsulate, authenticate, and potentially enhance long-term value.

Individually, each of these elements reinforces credibility. Collectively, they create confidence.
Importantly, these principles are not confined to trading cards. Elements such as serial numbering can apply to coins, while figures and other collectables may incorporate numbering and/or autographs. Trading cards, however, are where these elements most often converge, combining numbering, autographs, relic materials, licensing, and grading within a single,
purpose-built format.

None of this diminishes the importance of original artefacts. High-end collecting will always exist, and original instruments, costumes, and manuscripts will continue to command a premium. Museums and private collectors remain essential custodians of music history, preserving objects in context and ensuring their survival. Manufactured scarcity does not replace that role; it operates alongside it.

For most collectors, the choice is no longer between an original artefact and a licensed edition. It is between a licensed edition and nothing at all.

Manufactured scarcity may never satisfy the purist, but it has created something increasingly vital: a transparent and credible pathway for ordinary collectors to engage with music history without relying on unverifiable stories or blind faith. In a market where authenticity is everything, scarcity is no longer simply discovered. It is, increasingly, responsibly manufactured with regular collectors at its core.

---

Laurence Carpenter is one of the leading music memorabilia collectors and dealers in the world. He also curates pieces for the Grammy Museum, has been featured on British television and radio programs, and specializes in representing musicians, collectors, and their estates in the sale of their archives to research institutions and museums. Carpenter lives in Ireland where he is the Founder and Managing Director of Rock Solid Investments. If you’re considering buying or selling an item but are uncertain about the next steps, please don’t hesitate to reach out by email at laurence@popicons.com or at his website: RockSolidInvestments.ie

February 2026